×

Crosby,剧照,纳什和年轻盒装套装探讨了'deja vu'遍历再次:专辑评论

多数CDS的价值大多是未发布的演示和外出以及Cameron Crowe的漫长的历史论文加上了一个令人兴奋的经典,51年的纪念。

Joni Mitchell Rhino Neil Young Cameron
犀牛

各种产品和服务的所有产品和服务由各种编辑独立选择。BOB体育平台官网但是,各种可能会收BOB体育平台官网到通过其零售链接下的订单的佣金,零售商可以获得有关会计目的的某些可审计数据。

盒装套装可以包括数十个或甚至数百个未发行的曲目,从未见过的照片和大量的历史班轮笔记,但有时它真的只需要一个RaiLion d'Etre来证明其庞大的存在。与克罗斯比,剧照,纳什和年轻的新五盘“Déjàvu:50周年纪念版,”对我来说,一个单一的验证因素是存在“我们家”的演示版本格雷厄姆纳什然后他写的那个副手,Joni Mitchell.

谁知道这个存在?为什么在过去的51或52年之前,以前没有任何时间摇滚我们的世界?这不是那种喜欢找到一个耶稣自己把笔滚动的四个福音书中的一个稿件,只是为了强调好的部分?

好的,也许我有危险的危险。NASH / MITCHELL声乐协作是最粗略地记录的所有48个轨道遍布全新套件,由可能在原始盒式磁带播放器上按下“记录”的朋友录制。它被记录在纽约公寓,而不是工作室或实际的房子米切尔和纳什六人分享。But if you romanticize that period and that locale at all — and as last year’s documentary, “Laurel Canyon: A Place in Time” proved, a lot of us do — there’s a certain swooning that must be done in finally getting to hear the object of Nash’s affection sing along with him on the freshly written classic. Seemingly caught in a flub, he blurts out a“拉屎!”在他甚至遇到合唱之后,乔尼突然笑着笑了他的懊恼,然后她继续跳过他的旋律,甜蜜的和谐部分,这与什么不同斯蒂芬剧照大卫克罗斯比稍后会添加它。

Maybe this modest, raw demo won’t mean that much even to most of their fans… but for a certain subset of us, it’s like an archeologist came up with recorded proof that gods not only walked the earth, but that they shared hippie-dippy moments of domestic tranquility before everyone got kicked out of the garden.

和谐当然是克罗斯比,剧照,纳什和年轻人的关键词......在记录中。IRL,它在1969年后一步中被记录时的供应量减少,如卡梅隆群慷慨的班轮笔记篇章让我们提醒我们。可能有丝毫csny意识的任何人都有一个有意义的诉讼程序,其中四人中的每个人都有一个白人专辑方面,每个人都在整个工作室外,在将它们携带之前,或者在将它们携带之后Neil Young众所周知,在会议之后拿走了他与他在他面前的曲目的录像机,以自己结束。(去年,在去年的专辑实际的50岁生日之际,作者Steve Hochman有一个非常好的作品BOB体育平台官网将“Déjàvu”的想法Demythologizing作为群体努力的理想。)

懒惰的镜像
“Deja Vu:50周年版”来自Crosby,剧照,纳什&年轻人

然而,超级组是一个幻想的原因,如果不是最后49岁的现实,请给予或占领Wilburys,Highwaymen或Boygenius。我们希望相信孤独的游侠可以一起锁定。我们在很大程度上都相信它,因为,在足够的“Déjàvu”来加强任何人的摇摇欲坠的信仰,这些家伙所做的。即使是Neil“Quitter”年轻人甚至是在这张专辑的一二三拳匹紧的时候,随后的“俄亥俄州”/“找到了自由的成本”双人街“的成本,它专辑(以及一个四轮拳,如果你想包括1974年的旅行)让我们相信 - 哎呀,也让他们相信 - 那个短暂的团结是值得每一个肮脏的外观或敷料室斗争。听到他们的高峰来信CSNY是知道天使合唱团真的存在,有可能是即将到来的恶魔吉他问题,使其变得更加天堂。

但毫无疑问:如果这张专辑在音乐日的当前涂布中被妥善收费,那将是“克罗斯比,剧照和纳什壮举。尼尔年轻。“这与这个豪华版没有改变:据报道,年轻人拉动了一些奖金材料,这些材料会出现他的声音和歌曲,因此在演示和野外的圆盘中的存在甚至比他在原始专辑中所做的那样。不是他似乎对它完全羞耻,无论是:你可以在他的NYA(Neil Young Archives)网站上骄傲地找到完整的集合,他曾在“鸟儿”中唱歌的那个先前未发行的号码,“鸟类”已经获得了自己的抒情视频与他的摇晃的图片生产规范。据推测,他更愿意为“档案3”或“5.”持有“档案3”......But what we do get of Unheard Neil here also mostly falls into that price-of-admission-worth territory, whether it’s “Birds” — the noblest-sounding song ever written, maybe, about abandoning a chick — or the alternate version of Crosby’s “Almost Cut My Hair” that runs 10 minutes instead of the original album’s paltry four. Suffice it to say that none of the additional six minutes has to do with clipper near-misses and all of it is about the Stills/Young guitar interplay that for decades has been of rock’s greatest but most elusive elixirs.

除了年轻的“鸟类”(伴随着纳什陪同)之外,演示光盘在纳什,剧照和Crosby独奏声学试验之间相当分裂,并没有最终使历史记录 - 18。outtakes光盘由11个组合物的全频段版本组成,该组合物没有记录,而且这个特定的CD由丢失的剧本削减主导。And even if there was wisdom in setting aside most of the material in favor of what landed on the album, a whole disc’s worth of Stephen Stills working out what was, for him in 1970, B-grade material still amounts to an A+ experience, if only for the sure ambiance of soaking in the vibe the band had going on and particularly the creative fire that was going on in Stills’ soul. Some of these songs by S, C and N should have made一个专辑;幸运的是,一定的数量确实,不是这个。

These bonus tracks on discs 2 and 3 aren’t unlike the demos and rough tracks on the Beatles’ White Album and “Abbey Road” boxed sets, for the amount of first tries at songs that ended up on subsequent solo albums, or made their debut as live tracks “Four Way Street.” (Well, one of them wasn’t a first attempt; Crosby had already had his menage a trois song “Triad” recorded and rejected by the Byrds, before it got set aside here. His other “Déjà Vu” contributions were about reincarnation and being a hippie Samson, so it’s saying something that his threesome ode was still too weird for the record.) Nash’s “Right Between the Eyes” is a superior example of a non-country cheatin’ song, thinking of the cuckolded party in the adultery as he sings the memorable refrain, “A man’s a man that looks a man right between the eyes.” That song got its moment soon enough, anyway, on “4 Way Street,” as did Crosby’s “The Lee Shore” and even “Triad.” (Did someone say four-way? Don’t tell Croz.) It’s nice to have both solo and electric versions of “Laughing,” the anti-guru rejoinder to George Harrison’s spiritual pursuits that would end up on Crosby’s first solo album. A group version of John Sebastian’s “How Have You Been” is to die for and would have made a fine addition, even if it makes sense Sebastian kept it for his solo debut. Throw in Stills’ “Everyday We Live,” “Horses Through a Rainstorm” and a few others and it’s easy to imagine “Déjà Vu” having become a double-album, even if Young had kept saving most of his good stuff for his concurrently recorded “After the Goldrush” album.

至于创造记录的经典的早期草稿,“Déjàvu:50周年纪念版”再次就像那些上述披头士乐队的盒装套装,我们可以看到这些歌曲的一些歌曲不是是经典,相当,没有最终的声音排列或额外的旋律元素,它将它们送到顶部。对我来说,最令人迷人的是,对我来说,是“教你的孩子”的第一个演示版本,它只是在合唱团的尽头达成,而不是在“如果他们告诉你的话,你会哭”部分几代人已知和被爱。想想数百万篝火,可能已经过早地结束,潜在地将危险的余烬送入空中,如果这首歌没有成为上个世纪的伟大唱歌之一。只有“教你的孩子”可以防止森林火灾。

第四个CD,“替代,”是,是的,几乎完整专辑的替代版本。(It will be released on Record Store Day on its own as a single LP, a la Warner/Rhino’s tradition of issuing alternate “Moondances” or “Rumours” culled from boxed sets for RSD.) These aren’t all revelatory, though it’s interesting to hear “Teach” without the ingenious addition of neophyte pedal steel player Jerry Garcia or “Helpless” with a perhaps superfluous Neil harmonica part. For a finale, Stills’ “Everybody I Love You” is replaced by “Know You Got to Run,” and I think the album (which was always weakest in the final stretch) works just as well by ordering off the demos menu for a different closer.

第五个光盘是CD中的光盘1的Remastered原始专辑的LP版本。有些没有转盘可以考虑包含一个浪费的乙烯基浪费的时间,尽管很难想到大多数经典的摇滚球迷,但这些日子不是双重组织者,并感激有机会拥有o.g。LP都在两者中。In any case, Rhino’s penchant for including vinyl and doing most boxed sets as 12×12 packages has never been any better justified than it is in the case of “Déjà Vu,” where, if you’re of a certain age, you remember rubbing your fingers with glee over the unique fake leatherette of the gatefold LP jacket, lovingly reproduced here in all its tactile glory. (Crowe’s liner notes point out that the standard cost of manufacturing a gatefold cover in 1970 was 19 cents, but this album cost 69 cents. No wonder that a record company memo reproduced among the pictured artifacts warns that the list price for “Déjà Vu” will go up from $3.99 to a highway-robbery $4.99.)

克鲁的优秀班轮笔记,其中在数千个单词中运行,是一个有理由很高兴的原因,这个版本并没有减少到蛤壳包装,以及亨利德尔兹和原装夹克摄影师汤姆金德福格的照片会话的许多外面。(年轻人实际上在照片拍摄中拍摄了更多的时间,比在工作室里的CSN?这些是我们思考的东西。)克里,而不是出乎意料的,没有关于原始专辑的一切,依赖于最近对每个人的访谈而不是年轻......和for his recollections, he can crib notes from his own ’70s Q&As for Rolling Stone or Crawdaddy. What it often comes down to is that the boys were a mess. Romantically, Nash had split with Mitchell by the time the album came out, and Crosby had suffered the death of his girlfriend in a car accident early in its making, which left him curled up on the studio floor in a fetal ball. Throw in the more mundane squabbles about whether hundreds of takes were necessary and you’ve got a recipe for a kind ofdeja vu.他们不一定要立即重复。

但对于粉丝来说,想要再次听到它,并没有超过50年的减少。(或51 - 这之间,“塑料ono乐队”盒装套装,可能是其他人来,大流行导致我们一年晚于计划获得大量的档案。)专辑是否至少有稍微较暗的音调than the Young-less “Crosby, Stills & Nash” record that immediately preceded it in ’69? Sure — although an album with Nash leading the two greatest group-sings since Mitch Miller is only going to go所以黑暗的。它很好,也许甚至更好,这一个感觉更少地让阳光呢?也许更好的问题是:在空中做了一点张力毁了一个摇滚记录?在这种情况下,它没有。请记住,1970年最预期的专辑(而且包括披头士士单位亮相!)并没有作为一个失望的人来说,这也很有帮助,也没有觉得有一个半个世纪的后古。只有时间才能判断是否像十亿亿碳但是,你知道,它是一个良好的开端。

如果有一些关于整体的东西,就没有比零件更大,那么他们就是一些部分。米切尔的“伍德斯托克”的剧照封面是一个伟大的2场比赛,因为任何摇滚记录都有。但是,在我自己,目前正在渴望那个其他joni的时刻 - “我们的房子”演示有她的声音。When you’re having dental work done and they tell you to imagine something idyllic to get through it, the next time I’m in that situation, I might think of myself in that moment of time at their house in Laurel Canyon, maybe pre-incarnated as one of the two cats in the yard, listening in on counterculture icons creating their own version of domestic bliss.

Deja Vu - 50周年纪念日(豪华版)$ 88.94买它

Crosby,剧照,纳什和年轻盒装套装探讨了'deja vu'遍历再次:专辑评论

  • 生产:
  • 全体人员:
  • 投:
  • 音乐: